How to make chocolate brown paint
With a basic student palette, the closest first-try mix for chocolate brown (#5d3a1a) is Burnt Sienna + Sap Green + Burnt Umber at 2.5 : 1 : 1.
Best recipe
ΔE 1.8 · very close- Burnt Sienna2.5
- Sap Green1
- Burnt Umber1
Ratio: 2.5 : 1 : 1
Use your own paints, change the target or pick it from a photo.
How to mix it
- 1Put out Burnt Sienna first — it is the largest part of the mix.
- 2Add Sap Green + Burnt Umber a little at a time until you reach the ratio 2.5 : 1 : 1.
- 3Mix thoroughly with a palette knife and paint a small test swatch next to your reference.
- 4Let the swatch dry, compare again and adjust — most paints dry slightly darker.
Tips for mixing chocolate brown
Browns are mixed complements: an orange or red earth plus a little blue. Burnt Sienna with a touch of Ultramarine is the classic base; add yellow to warm it or white to soften it.
First-try ratio: mix a small amount, paint a swatch next to your reference and adjust by eye.
Other ways to mix it
Recipe 2
ΔE 2.8 · close- Burnt Sienna8
- Phthalo Green1
Ratio: 8 : 1
Recipe 3
ΔE 2.0 · close- Burnt Sienna40
- Sap Green8
- Ivory Black3
Ratio: 40 : 8 : 3
Questions about mixing chocolate brown
What colors make chocolate brown paint?
With a basic palette, mix Burnt Sienna + Sap Green + Burnt Umber at 2.5 : 1 : 1. The predicted result is very close to chocolate brown (ΔE 1.8).
Can I make chocolate brown with only two paints?
The closest two-paint mix is Burnt Sienna + Phthalo Green at 8 : 1, which is close to the target (ΔE 2.8).
How do I make chocolate brown lighter or darker?
To lighten it, add white in small steps (or water for watercolor). To darken it without making it muddy, add a little more of the darkest paint in the recipe instead of black.
Why does my chocolate brown look different from the preview?
Brands use different pigments and paint changes as it dries. Treat the ratio as a first try, compare a dry swatch with your reference and adjust by eye.
Calculated with the student palette: Titanium White, Ivory Black, Lemon Yellow, Cadmium Yellow (Hue), Yellow Ochre, Cadmium Red, Alizarin Crimson, Ultramarine Blue, Phthalo Blue, Phthalo Green, Sap Green, Burnt Sienna, Burnt Umber, Raw Umber, Dioxazine Purple.